• Category Archives Book Related
  • Chronicles of Elantra #10-13

    Michelle Sagara’s Chronicles of Elantra series is a bit different than most in that rather than a collection of related stories it’s more like one continuous story; the breaks between books are not much different from the breaks between chapters. As a result it can occasionally be somewhat frustrating to read, due to creating the illusion that the character development should be greater than it is.

    Cast in Flame isn’t as abstract as the previous book in the series, and I’m immensely thankful for that. That said, the whole ‘heart of the house’ activation scene felt like a copy-paste of the Tiamaris claiming. The follow-up, Cast in Honor, is on the borderline when it comes to abstraction and features some interesting developments regarding both the shadow and Bellusdeo.

    Cast in Flight is one of the more stand-alone books, which is to say that its central plotline is relatively self-contained and it doesn’t really leave any major loose-ends behind. It’s a nice change of pace after the previous two entries. The 13th book on the other hand both leaves several major loose ends dangling and starts off badly. Very badly. It’s not until about a third of the way through that events and character behavior become less… grating. But they do indeed get better and I’m definitely looking forward to the continuation.


  • Sideswiped, The Drafter, & Once Broken Faith

    The Kim Harrison novella Sideswiped, a work meant to introduce you to the world of Peri Reed, is pretty bad. Both in its technical aspects and in the near-total lack of relevance it has to the first main novel in the series.

    Which would be The Drafter. After the terrible showing of the previous story (and preview first chapter) I waffled back and forth quite a bit over whether or not to give this a proper chance… and I should have went with my initial plan of ignoring it. While certainly better than Sideswiped it unfortunately has some major characterization and plot-related problems and isn’t very enjoyable in any respect. One interesting thing about it though is how, rather than an agency thriller, it comes off more like a gender equality allegory.

    Switching authors now, Seanan McGuire‘s Once Broken Faith is the tenth October Daye novel and does something a bit refreshing. Rather than further escalate matters it decides to take a step horizontally and introduce a number of the other North American Fae rulers while wrapping up both the aftermath of having found the antidote and (with the help of a bonus short story) the Queen of Mists’ situation. It’s a solid balance of humor, action, drama, and world-building.


  • The Witch With No Name, The Great Ordeal, & The Unholy Consult

    The concluding novel in Kim Harrison‘s Hollows series makes it fairly clear that the series has been dragged out far beyond its expiration point with power-level creep that’s both ridiculous and inconsistent. Roughly half the book is someone doing something awful, blaming Rachel for it, and having everyone believe them for no apparent reason, while a quarter consists of Rachel beating herself up about ‘holding Trent back’. Only ~25% or so of it is decent-to-good and you wouldn’t lose much by just skipping straight to the epilogue chapter.

    Originally R. Scott Bakker’s Aspect-Emperor series was meant to be a trilogy, but after a lengthy delay it ended up becoming a quartet. It’s very fortunate that The Great Ordeal is preceded by a detailed recap of what came before, because after nearly a half-decade gap I doubt many remember previous events at all clearly. It’s also fortunate that the book turns out to feel more like the earlier Prince of Nothing novels. I still don’t like the Esmenet/Kel sections at all though.

    The Unholy Consult is a bit different though in that the disparate storylines are mostly merged into a single narrative while the vast majority of the book focuses on one battle. Ultimately I don’t think these two needed to be separate novels, as there are a number of aspects that end up completely superfluous (such as the Sorwheel/Serwa and White Luck subplots) or orphaned (those ‘vile angel’ interludes). The conclusion deserves special mention for being so… random? Though there’s a certain symmetry to the one person not damned being responsible for damnation, the way it happens does not feel natural in the slightest. It’s almost like an after-thought.


  • Magic Binds, Assorted Short Stories, & The Turn

    Ilona Andrews’ ninth Kate Daniels novel forces Kate to fully embrace her power and brings the conflict with her father to a head. Presumably the 10th book will be the series finale and this one does a pretty fantastic job of setting the stage while being entertaining in its own right.

    There are many short stories in the Kate Daniels series that are scattered about. Several were collected into the Small Magics E-book, and of these the first two are probably the best while the second-to-last gives an interesting glimpse into a pre-shift time. Others have been released as stand-alone E-books, such as Magic Stars (which is decent), Magic Dreams (which is okayish, having originally been released in the anthology Hexed), and Magic Steals (which is similar to Dreams for obvious reasons but works better). All of them help flesh out the world and are worth taking a look at so long as you don’t mind bite-sized episodic stories.

    Changing gears we come to The Turn, which is a prequel to the Hollows series that centers on Trent’s parents and how the virus that decimated humanity came into being. While it starts out good, once the plague is loosed and the focus shifts over toward action and demon summoning it does not hold up well at all; the scenes don’t really gel and most of the character behavior goes to shit. Rather than being its own thing it instead transforms into a pale imitation of the main series.


  • A Red-Rose Chain, Magic Breaks, & Magic Shifts

    Seanan McGuire‘s A Red-Rose Chain has an ending problem; it’s both anti-climatic and rather abrupt. The journey up to that point is entertaining for the most part though, with the only hiccup being a bizarre page-and-a-half dialog regarding a character dramatically revealed to be transsexual. Why is there such a hamfisted focus on it? I don’t recall any particular attention being drawn to May’s lesbian relationship before, and this should have been no different.

    As for Ilona AndrewsMagic Breaks and Magic Shifts: The first acts as a conclusion of sorts to the background conflict that has been building from the very first entry in the series, while the second continues on in a slightly different yet still quite similar direction. There’s a comforting familiarity about them that was absent from their more recent prequels.


  • The Mortal Instruments, Hardship, & Damnation

    The Mortal Instruments series originally ended as a trilogy, and it was a pretty good ending that felt like an ending… but then the author decided to extend it into a six-part series, the fourth and fifth of which (City of Fallen Angels, City of Lost Souls) are something of a slog. They just feel completely extraneous, as if they don’t really have anything new to say; existing solely to drag the story out and ruin the conclusion of the third book. The sixth however (City of Heavenly Fire) is actually fairly engaging and almost justifies the existence of the two preceding books. The ending isn’t really an ending though and it handles the Simon issue rather horribly.

    Hardship and Damnation are the final two books in Jean Johnson‘s Theirs Not To Reason Why series. The first of them is only so-so and seems a little forced and overly limited, but the second works quite well and wraps the series up nicely. I can’t say I’m not interested in a sequel that covers the future timeline that this series spends so much effort preparing for.


  • Books; Before and After

    First the before, which was three books read back in August:

    Jean le Flambeur – This trilogy by Hannu Rajaniemi reminded me of two other authors’ styles. The first book (The Quantum Thief) was reminiscent of Jack Vance, the second (The Fractal Prince) of R. Scott Bakker, and the third (The Causal Angel) a combination of the two. These books do not explain what’s going on. Rather, they show you what’s going on and trust that you’ll be able to understand/decipher the terminology and happenings on your own. It’s… certainly interesting.

    And now the after, three books I just read yesterday. The first since the trilogy above:

    The Winter Long – Seanan McGuire’s eighth October Daye novel apparently kicks off the ‘main’ plotline that’s been simmering in the background since Rosemary and Rue. Which is not to say that things have changed all that much, as it’s still fundamentally the same series it has always been… just with higher overall power levels.

    Unbinding – This eleventh Lupi novel is focused on wrapping up the loose ends from the tenth and is told from the perspective of the mindhealer Kai. There’s not really much to say about it honestly, since if you’ve been reading this far into the series you already know what to expect and this doesn’t do anything in particular to shake things up. One aspect stands out though, and that’s the possible newfound focus on marrying off its characters. I don’t really like the message this appears to be trying to send; that somehow ‘officially’ being bound to your SO should be important for the relationship in any way, shape, or form. Of course I highly doubt anyone impressionable enough to have their views on the subject changed will be reading a series like this in the first place, so I suppose it doesn’t matter much.

    Havoc – The second part of Ann Aquirre’s Dred Chronicles series is sort of so-so. I wasn’t really sure where things could go from the first book, and this one just feels like an excessive escalation. I also don’t remember the central government being so ridiculously corrupt in the Sirantha Jax novels (this takes place in the same universe), which caused some cognitive dissonance. It’s okay I guess, it just lacks solidity and doesn’t come across as particularly believable.


  • Indexing, Skin Game, & Some Other Books

    May as well get these out of the way while I’m updating things. Read them months ago and just couldn’t be bothered recording them.

    • Seanan McGuire‘s Indexing is pretty good. It’s a bit busy and the fairy tale elements are obviously contrived, yet it manages to work for the most part rather well.
    • The most recent Dresden Files installment, Skin Game, makes me start to seriously wonder what I ever liked about the series. To be fair I actually started wondering that last installment, but this one really drives the feeling home. The relationship between Dresden and Murphy, the light saber, his self-moral questioning… it’s all just cringe-worthy. There are a few notably well-done scenes, but for the most part it just seems incredibly juvenile.
    • The fourth book in Keri Arthur’s Nikki and Michael series is shockingly enough not awful. Rather, Kiss the Night Goodbye is merely average.
    • The Damask Circle series, also by Keri Arthur, ties into the above series. Its first three entries (Circle of Fire/Death/Desire) are all both episodic and more or less as painfully generic as a paranormal romance can be.
    • And finally we come to Cecy Robson, the author of the Weird Girls series. I found the first book to be one of the worst I’ve ever had the misfortune of reading, so of course (of course) the second and third ones were pre-ordered and showed up shortly after. The second, A Cursed Embrace, is so horrific I could not finish it… not even by skimming. In fact, it single-handily nearly destroyed my desire to ever pick up a paperback again. I flat-out refuse to so much as even open the third book.

  • Of Heroes and Villains

    I do not have a high opinion of web-based publishing sites. In my experience, most of the stories found on them are far below the quality of even the worst supermarket paperback you may pick up. I stumbled across a link a few days ago however which lead to two particular stories, Of Heroes and Villains and the sequel The Ties That Bind (both by the relatively new author Minikisa), which are fairly impressive.

    I would say they are easily on par with your average paperback romance/paranormal romance novel and are indeed actually of a notably higher quality. I know, I know; low bar. Still, it’s something worth noting. Anyway you should judge for yourself. A few preliminary words of warning however:

    The first of these stories is heavily focused on a Male-to-Female transgender, and so if you find that uncomfortable for whatever reason I do not think it would be a good idea to read it. While the setting and characters are very good, the gender identity conflict is rather central and so dislike of that aspect will probably result in dislike of the entire thing. The second story however just has some temporary body-swapping and so should be more or less fine for anyone. Oh, and yeah, there are a few sexual scenes scattered about (more in the first, though neither story makes them the focus).

    Of Heroes And Villains
    The Ties That Bind


  • Relatively Recent Books

    Been procrastinating with adding these because it’s a pain. May as well get it over with now:

    • Sealed with a Curse (Cecy Robson) – Real bad. Basically all the worst Urban Fantasy and Paranormal Romance tropes/stereotypes mashed together. One of the characters having a surfer-dude accent for whateverthehell reason just made it all the more aggravating.
    • Allegiant (Veronica Roth) – Honestly, it’s been so long since I read this that my only recollection is liking how Tris’ story turned out while disliking the somewhat circular nature of the plot developments.
    • The Razorland Trilogy (Ann Aguirre) – The first book starts out good but seems to lose its way toward the end when the protagonists start picking up party members like a RPG. The second shifts between being interesting and being annoying (the latter mostly caused by the whole gender roles focus), and the third is readable enough even though it wraps everything up a little too neatly.
    • Red Delicious (Caitlín R. Kiernan) – Usually when people dislike something, they’ll just make a blog/forum post about it. Kiernan (as Kathleen Tierney) goes the extra mile and writes a book about it. This reads like an open letter regarding all the sorts of books/genres and literary criticisms she hates and frankly just comes across as rather sad posturing.
    • Wild Justice (Kelley Armstrong) – Fairly interesting continuation of the Nadia Stafford series that focuses on both Nadia’s past and her current relationship with Jack. There are a few things off about the ending stretch that sort of dull its sheen though.
    • The Undead Pool (Kim Harrison) – A more or less solid continuation of the series focused on vampires, elves, and Trent/Rachel’s relationship.