• Tag Archives Young Adult Novel
  • Thirteenth Child Trilogy & Elise Kova

    Patricia C. Wrede‘s Thirteenth Child trilogy is a very slow burn; don’t go into it expecting a hero’s journey. Instead it’s closer to an alternative history slice of life series, with each book being ~90% focused on the protagonist’s daily interactions/activities and only the last chapter or two providing an opportunity for her to do something that catches everyone’s attention. There are also a number of loose ends relating to the world’s metaphysics and the tendency for a chapter to end with a dire proclamation only to have nothing come of it in the next is a consistent annoyance. Yet despite all that there’s just something about Wrede’s dialog style that makes the journey entertaining enough to forgive the open-ended and somewhat anti-climatic conclusion.

    Elise Kova’s Golden Guard trilogy is less a trilogy and more a loose collection of short stories. The first is a bit of an action-mystery, but besides that is hard to pin down. The second is a painfully generic paranormal romance story minus the paranormal. The third is something of a buddy comedy. All three together are about the size of one normal book and honestly I can’t recommended bothering with them since they add nothing to the sequel.

    That sequel being her previously published Air Awakens series. Interestingly enough the genre here is different from all three of the short stories mentioned above, with this being something of a combination hero’s journey paranormal romance. It starts out slow, picks up in the second book, begins to fall apart in the third, completely falls apart in the fourth, and takes a hard turn into pitch black tragedy in the the fifth: Human mutation, cannibalism, incest, miscarriage, and mental corruption/degradation all make an appearance. Ultimately I can’t recommended this series either due to all the inconsistencies surrounding the protagonist.

    Unrelated to the the two works above (though almost immediately recognizable as from the same author due to the fondness for using names over pronouns), Kova’s Loom Saga is a relatively straightforward paranormal romance story for the most part which quickly brought to mind Lilith Saintcrow’s Dante Valentine series. This series leans more toward steampunk instead of cyberpunk though and takes place in its own fantasy world. While the first book is pretty good and the second is decent, the third comes across as very unfocused and almost offhanded in how everything gets resolved; what ends up most interesting about it is how Arianna ends up ceding the protagonist spot to Florence.


  • The Mortal Instruments, Hardship, & Damnation

    The Mortal Instruments series originally ended as a trilogy, and it was a pretty good ending that felt like an ending… but then the author decided to extend it into a six-part series, the fourth and fifth of which (City of Fallen Angels, City of Lost Souls) are something of a slog. They just feel completely extraneous, as if they don’t really have anything new to say; existing solely to drag the story out and ruin the conclusion of the third book. The sixth however (City of Heavenly Fire) is actually fairly engaging and almost justifies the existence of the two preceding books. The ending isn’t really an ending though and it handles the Simon issue rather horribly.

    Hardship and Damnation are the final two books in Jean Johnson‘s Theirs Not To Reason Why series. The first of them is only so-so and seems a little forced and overly limited, but the second works quite well and wraps the series up nicely. I can’t say I’m not interested in a sequel that covers the future timeline that this series spends so much effort preparing for.


  • Relatively Recent Books

    Been procrastinating with adding these because it’s a pain. May as well get it over with now:

    • Sealed with a Curse (Cecy Robson) – Real bad. Basically all the worst Urban Fantasy and Paranormal Romance tropes/stereotypes mashed together. One of the characters having a surfer-dude accent for whateverthehell reason just made it all the more aggravating.
    • Allegiant (Veronica Roth) – Honestly, it’s been so long since I read this that my only recollection is liking how Tris’ story turned out while disliking the somewhat circular nature of the plot developments.
    • The Razorland Trilogy (Ann Aguirre) – The first book starts out good but seems to lose its way toward the end when the protagonists start picking up party members like a RPG. The second shifts between being interesting and being annoying (the latter mostly caused by the whole gender roles focus), and the third is readable enough even though it wraps everything up a little too neatly.
    • Red Delicious (Caitlín R. Kiernan) – Usually when people dislike something, they’ll just make a blog/forum post about it. Kiernan (as Kathleen Tierney) goes the extra mile and writes a book about it. This reads like an open letter regarding all the sorts of books/genres and literary criticisms she hates and frankly just comes across as rather sad posturing.
    • Wild Justice (Kelley Armstrong) – Fairly interesting continuation of the Nadia Stafford series that focuses on both Nadia’s past and her current relationship with Jack. There are a few things off about the ending stretch that sort of dull its sheen though.
    • The Undead Pool (Kim Harrison) – A more or less solid continuation of the series focused on vampires, elves, and Trent/Rachel’s relationship.

  • Daughter of Smoke & Bone & As the World Dies

    I read the first two books in Laini Taylor’s Daughter of Smoke & Bone series a few months ago, and put off commenting on them for this long for reasons mentioned in the second part of this post. I remember little about them now besides that the first book was very, very interesting while the second (Days of Blood & Starlight) felt like it got lost within its own mythology. The connection to the ‘real world’ was almost entirely severed and it shifts from being Urban Fantasy to almost pure Fantasy. It’s not a shift I was particularly fond of. The way it concluded though indicates that the third book might have more of a mix to it.

    The As the World Dies trilogy is a set of zombie novels by Rhiannon Frater (The First Days, Fighting to Survive, Siege) whose first installment starts out fantastic. As things progress however and the main characters reach ‘The Fort’ it starts to fall apart. Maybe it was the strain of trying to create unique voices for so many different characters, but the end result is a collection of… well… characters. Characterizations rather than people. They feel fabricated, typecast. I ended up having to force myself through the second book and was so put-off by the dialog that I avoided reading the third for almost three months. Just read it now, finally, and… I don’t even know. Mysticism was introduced out of nowhere to completely dominate the story and end things on a… happy, I guess, note. It reminds me of how reincarnation was pulled out of thin air in Nalini Singh’s Guild Hunter series or of what I’ve heard regarding the ending to Lost.